This interview originally aires on October 29, 2026
Velvet Einstein: I am your host, Velvet Einstein, and a couple weeks ago I had the extreme pleasure of speaking with producer Ian Brennan, who’s done a number of remarkable recordings, including Himba Hymn Ghosts of Namibia’s Skeleton Coast, and Land of the Sun, featuring the Red Spirit Singers from the Ute Nation in Utah. And I spoke with him about those. So let’s go ahead and have a listen to that. But first, I want to play a track from one of his recent releases. This is from the Oman Bagpipe Singers to give you a sense of the type of recordings that Ian does. And this is I Hear a Noise on the Thatched Roof and It Reminds Me How Much I Miss Home. Again, this is music of the Oman Bagpipe Singers as recorded by Ian Brennan.
Musical Interlude
Ian Brennan: You’re listening to KALX Berkeley, and you’re very lucky to be doing so. And this is Ian Brennan, a music producer. I was born in Oakland, so growing up, this is what I listened to, and thank goodness for that. So keep listening to this and not to streaming and not to Universal Music and all the people that control this stuff, but the real music that’s coming from all kinds of different places around the world that normally gets ignored.
Velvet Einstein: Thank you, Ian. Guess that’s a good way to get into talking about what you do, right? You go around the world, and you find music from all different parts of the world. You’ve had a number of great releases out this year, including the Red Spirit Singers Land of the Sun, Oman Bagpipe Singers, The Himba Hymn: Ghosts of Namibia’s Skeleton Coast, and the Chicago Gunfire Survivors release. And that was just this year, so you’ve certainly been busy.
Ian Brennan: Yeah. I’ve been very fortunate, and I was just thinking about it today actually, on the way over here. I think about it often, how fortunate I am to meet people around the world, and there’s so many talented people, and they have so much to offer, the diverse voices.
I think that’s what gets lost with the superstar system because it’s designed to create industrial products. So someone like Taylor Swift, artistry aside one way or the other, is an industrial product that they can sell and fill stadiums that the billionaires own. And yet there’s great music everywhere that is not going to appeal to so many people, but has as much, if not more, value.
I’ve been really lucky to meet so many people and to keep doing that. The sad part of it, of course, is that there’s fewer and fewer outlets for the music, and one of the reasons there are so many releases this year, and have been for many years now, is because we have a backlog of stuff. You know, there’s a lot of great stuff.
I recorded some great stuff just this weekend, but who knows when and if it will ever even be heard. Some of the stuff has been waiting for years, and so hopefully, one day, all of it will get out there. But there’s no such thing as an amusical place. That’s the big myth that gets pushed forward oftentimes most of all by musicologists who want to claim that some places are more musical than others.
And yeah, maybe there’s a continuum, but in general, living without music is an impossibility really. So there are no asexual people, otherwise they wouldn’t reproduce, and there certainly are no amusical people, otherwise they wouldn’t survive. They wouldn’t survive spiritually as a people.
Velvet Einstein: And in terms of all the diversity that you have of the recordings that you do, is there a through line in terms of how you’re introduced to people, or is each one very unique and we’ll have to just kind of take them one at a time? Or is there a pattern to how you’re able to find all these incredible artists?
Ian Brennan: Well, it’s been very different from case to case. And so over time, in a sense, it gets easier just because trusting more in my instincts and being more willing to take leaps of faith. But it’s funny how a lot of the music is found, and a lot of it’s found through other musicians.
So in other words, you meet somebody who’s recommended. And that person then, through them you meet somebody else who’s actually oftentimes more compelling but maybe not as successful. And so the people that are introducing those folks maybe are not, quote unquote, “famous,” but they’re oftentimes people that are more commercial and maybe have governmental ties locally.
But the best stuff, I think, in the history of music is usually folk music, meaning played by people that are doing it simply for the sake of expressing themselves to each other musically or entertaining each other. And that largely died with radio and then television, and even more so now with the internet.
But it’s still alive in some places. And I think it can be reborn also. You see that occur. And so the people are there. It’s just a matter of finding them. But what I do know is you can’t find people on the internet. If it’s on the internet it’s already bad or too late. You know, it’s… meaning it’s already kind of tied into the system as it exists.
Velvet Einstein: Yeah. And, and you’ve written about your travels. And I think at least once, probably several times, you talk about how you would go in, and there would be the guy there with all the bravado who thinks that he’s the big guns and wants to be recorded by you. And then you wind up then realizing he’s very boring, and that the person behind them is the more interesting one. Is that a common experience?
Ian Brennan: It is a common experience. And I don’t say that with any resentment or a chip on my shoulder towards those people. But in general, it’s the humble people that are the most compelling, and the meek even. The ones that say, “I’m not a singer,” are oftentimes the best singers.
And when I say best, I mean the strongest and most unique, which is the measure that I use. It’s not do I like something personally, but is this something I’ve never heard before? And if it’s something I’ve never heard before, then that has value. It used to be, until pretty recently, that 100,000 songs are uploaded to Spotify daily.
They just recently published in Billboard that it’s 150,000 songs uploaded to Spotify daily, more than anybody could ever listen to, even if it was their job and they never slept. So it’s the people that most want to be heard that tend to be heard. But I would argue that it’s the people who are oftentimes not looking for attention and are ignored that tend to really, really have the most to share.
And a fairer system, a more democratic system would be hearing from more people, one song from everybody, not, you know, the same songs over and over again for decade after decade after decade after decade after decade. And somebody like the Eagles is the classic example of that. Again, whether people like it or don’t like it, I actually like some of their tunes, but they are the classic example of something that’s been set up to perpetuate itself and is perpetuating itself even in the absence of most of the original members.
And that music has been heard so redundantly, and that’s not healthy. It’s not healthy culturally, it’s not healthy neurologically, but also it displaces all the great stuff that the majority don’t get to hear. And KALX and, and stations like it and outlets like it are so important, and they’re fewer and far between now because they help expose at least some people that are active in the process of seeking music to find music that otherwise they probably would not be able to.
And yet the majority, I believe, have better taste than it might be assumed. In other words, if they were really truly given the chance to listen to stronger, more original, more vibrant music, they would. But in public spaces, you just hear the same things over and over again, in that which is corporately controlled.
And as these companies buy up these song catalogs for hundreds of millions of dollars, it’s very clear that they aren’t doing that out of charity to millionaires like Bruce Springsteen. They’re doing this because they are committed to the future sounding exactly like our past.
Velvet Einstein: Then for you, as you go around and you visit with these communities that are off the beaten path and not tied into the internet as much, what are you seeing in terms of the distribution of the Eagles, of Michael Jackson, of reggae music, in terms of what people outside of the U.S. and similar countries are experiencing in terms of this?
Ian Brennan: Yeah, I mean, reggae is something that is genuinely many places, particularly in Africa, and is permeated. You know, the original distributors of music were two, and they’re interrelated, and that is the militaries, you know, when they go, and the colonialists, the military bands. And so a lot of those instruments, especially brass instruments and drums, were brought by military forces around the world.
Also, well, the missionaries that are bringing these songs. So that basic structure that you hear in hymnals is found throughout the world in many places, especially those that have been heavily…or missionaries have been heavily concentrated. But as far as the West and this idea that the people are listening to these mighty people like the Eagles and the Beatles, it just isn’t so.
But nonetheless, you will hear Hotel California in a public space. Almost everywhere we’ve ever been you’ll hear it. But people don’t know what it is and they wouldn’t listen to it in most cases voluntarily. And so I do the little check-in with people everywhere we go in the world if given a chance, and that is I say, “Well, you know, do you know who The Beatles are?”
And no, they don’t know who The Beatles are. “Do you know who Bob Dylan is?” No, don’t know who Bob Dylan is. Even within Africa, “Do you know who Fela Kuti is?” A lot of people don’t. “Do you know who Angelique Kidjo is?” Almost no one knows who Angelique Kidjo is in Africa. Certain parts, yes. And if they do, a lot of times that’s an indicator of somebody who is more mobile, more economically advantaged, has traveled to Europe, has traveled to America, or been educated there, or lives there.
That’s not what we’re talking about. We’re talking about the majority, and certainly people in the rural areas still to this day don’t listen to tons of recorded music and that allows for them to make more music. But even there, the tradition is dying in most cases. The tradition of building instruments, the tradition of making music, all those things are going away largely because it’s becoming more and more of a visual culture globally, where people want to look at stuff.
They don’t necessarily want to listen to it. Popular music is certainly not central in the West anymore. It’s more of an ancillary thing to, to support video games and films, et cetera, for most people. And in other parts of the world, it’s slowly lessening in terms of its role.
And I’ll give you an example of that is in Laos we were recording and there was somebody from the Hmong people, and he builds kuams, which are these beautiful horns of varying sizes. And he’s built many of them of different sizes, and his little storage area is just stuffed with them because nobody wants them anymore. You know, before it was an occupation, where almost every village and many people in the same village would want these, and now they’re just there, just wasting away.
Velvet Einstein: That’s tragic. Yeah.
Ian Brennan: It is in a sense, yeah.
Velvet Einstein: I want to talk a little bit about specifics of some of the recordings, so maybe we can start with Namibia, which that release from your description was really off the beaten path. What was it, a 25 hour, four-day drive to get there? Can you talk a little bit about the people that you recorded there?
Ian Brennan: We’re talking about the Himba record. Yeah. It was one of the more remote areas we’ve ever been to because we had to drive, I don’t even remember all the numbers at this point, but a long, long drive up the main road to a town in the north. And then from there you have to go off-road for eight to 10 hours, and it’s a pretty rough drive, through rivers and a couple of little tiny mountain passages where the road is narrow.
And then when you get there, you’re close to the ocean. You’re close to the Atlantic Ocean, and it’s incredibly beautiful, that area. And so we were there, we recorded with the folks, and we were really intent on this idea of listening to them and not objectifying them. Because visually they’ve been very focused on because of their traditions. One tradition is women going around topless, and another tradition is the use of mud in the hair and on the body sometimes as well.
And so we were telling them, and in fact, the night we finally got there, I met some of the folks that were going to be singing and really reiterated again, “Hey, you can wear whatever you want. You don’t have to wear traditional stuff. You’re not performing for us. It’s not a show. We’re just there to listen to you and, and to share the moment with you.”
And most of these guys were wearing some mix of clothes like shorts and T-shirts and hats and things that could come from the West, and a lot of them had. But the next day, they did all show up in traditional costumes nonetheless, and again, the women all showed up topless.
So Marilena Umuhoza Delli, my wife, who does all the video and photographs, was very careful in photographing, especially the women, to try to photograph them in a way that was de-emphasizing that they were exotic, but was emphasizing the humanity and the individuality of the people. And I think the record is very futuristic, and I think the record is…there’s traditional elements.
They’re using a traditional instrument. Really the only instrument that’s being used is the official instrument. It’s called the cattle horn, and it’s rare now. It’s another one that everybody used to have, and now it’s quite expensive because it’s so rare. But it’s just a long horn of a type of antelope essentially covered in mud, and that’s their main instrument.
Everything else is voices and hands and feet, you know, meaning clapping and stomping. But it’s not traditional music. It’s very much of the present, and it’s very much ultimately of the future. I think it sounds a lot more creative and progressive than a lot of the people that might claim themselves to be, who are kind of being weird for weird’s sake or strange for strange’s sake. So it, it was an incredibly beautiful experience to meet the people there.
Velvet Einstein: You’ve been listening to the voice of producer Ian Brennan from a recent interview, talking there about the release Himba Hymn: Ghosts of Namibia’s Skeleton Coast. So let’s go ahead and have a listen to a track from that and then get back into the interview. This is the piece Be Brave in the Face of Death.
Musical Interlude
Velvet Einstein: And it does make me think of the notion of authenticity. Do you feel that that is part of your responsibility as a producer is to capture something that is authentic?
Ian Brennan: Truthful, not authentic. I think these words authentic and genuine are very dangerous words. The recordings process itself is always going be artificial. It always has been. The history of particularly roots music, which is kind of the root of everything in popular music, that came out of America and now is spread over the world, that was largely based on people coming in and, you know, picking and choosing what they were going to demonstrate or what they were going to show of different artists.
So in reality, a lot of the Black and white artists in the South were playing a lot of the same songs, a lot of the same repertoire. But they would eliminate the songs, the bluesier songs by a lot of the white artists. They would eliminate a lot of the more country songs of the Black artists, and then market them differently as if they were very different from each other when in fact they weren’t.
And musicians have always been the ones that are integrating. Music really is a bridge between people, so you know, they’re backstage, onstage, in recordings. They’re sharing a lot with one another oftentimes. So when we talk about these forms, like this weekend was Hardly Strictly Bluegrass. Well, you know, these forms become very codified, but a lot of it is a repetition of something that was a moving target that got fixed in place by recording.
So in other words, they recorded some artist in a hotel room for a couple hours, and then that got turned into a record, and that became the template for a genre of music. But if you’d recorded those same artists a day earlier or a month later, probably it would’ve been different. And there was a lot of improvisation in all those musical forms, and also massive repertoires because most of them, when they performed, had to perform for four or five hours all night long.
There was no alternative for people. There was no television. There was no radio. There was no jukebox. And so they had these huge bodies of work that were getting whittled down to just one thing. And so then it becomes this repetition and repetition and repetition and repetition of these genres that in fact in a sense never really existed to begin with. They only exist through the imagination of people as that’s what there was. But there was so much more that was not allowed to be heard.
Velvet Einstein: And do you, as a producer, worry about yourself having that effect? In that you recorded the Himba Hymn, and now people are going to associate that one recording because unfortunately, there’s not other recordings out there.
Ian Brennan: Yeah, there’s always these worries, you know, in terms of the ethics of it and also the impact. But it’s very easy in a sense to solve that by just looking at the massive inequality, and so we have to start somewhere. So in other words, I was doing a class recently at a conservatory, not a class, but a talk.
And like everywhere else, I ask people, “Okay, what are your favorite bands from England? What are your favorite bands from America? Now let’s get hyper-specific. What are your favorite bands from Los Angeles? What are your favorite bands from New York? What are your favorite bands from London?” And almost always people have no problem naming one, two, three, four, five, you know, each person of artists in this case.
Then it shifts into, “What’s your favorite artist from Suriname? What’s your favorite artist from, you know, Pakistan even?” And usually they can’t name one. And so the point is at least one record. Hopefully, that isn’t the only record, but at least one record there. Because there shouldn’t just be an album that people are aware of from every country in the world and in every language in the world, the thousands and thousands of languages.
There should be many just like there are from here. So part of the problem is, it’s just reflected in every other way, is this disproportionate representation where there’s all these records that more or less sound the same coming from America, coming from Brooklyn, coming from Silver Lake, coming from here, coming from there. There’s marginal difference between them, and then you have internationally almost no representation for most other people in the world.
Velvet Einstein: Yeah. It is a challenge, and that kind of reminds me of in your book, Missing Music: Voices From Where The Dirt Roads End, you do have at the end six simple daily practices to reclaim your media environment and appreciate it. Yeah, number four, “Force yourself to listen to at least one new song a day that you don’t like, or is a song in a language you don’t understand. Actively open yourself to difference.”
Ian Brennan: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I think it’s important. You know, and as streaming discourages that. You know, it’s the exact opposite. In fact, people have begun to make music differently to fit… It’s cart before the horse…to fit the algorithm and the audience’s attention span. So the idea of the builds, I mean, so many great classic songs, there’s so much about the build. A one or two minute build that oftentimes is very different than the song itself, and that’s gone. I’m not saying it doesn’t exist anywhere, but it’s certainly discouraged where you just gotta get right to the hook and jump in.
Velvet Einstein: Yeah, I’m laughing because we’ve recently had issues here where promoters will send us the radio edit of a song, and we’re like, “We’re a freeform college station here. We want the build!” Tight? Because that’s inevitably what the radio edit is-
Ian Brennan: Right …
Velvet Einstein: is they cut out the good part.
Ian Brennan: Yeah, yeah. And it is oftentimes the good part. But also, I think that when people had to physically buy music to hear it, one of the advantages of that… There’s a lot of disadvantages, but one of the advantages of that is that, A, you had to be active in the process and selective in the process.
And for me growing up, a lot of that was just honing your instincts and trying to figure out if inside this thing wrapped in plastic, the artwork indicates and the song titles indicate that maybe this is something that’s going to resonate. And sometimes it was misleading, but a lot of times it was very in tune with maybe a sense of what the music would be like.
But then you would end up buying things a lot of times that you didn’t like, and the beauty of that was that you’d usually give it a second try, a third try, a fourth try, a fifth try, because you’d invested in it. You’d spent money, and you couldn’t get the money back. And some of that music didn’t deserve that attention, but a lot of times it’s music that needs that attention, because I don’t think anybody…Ornette Coleman’s Free Jazz, anybody that says they like that the first time they listen to it is just lying. So it requires attention, and then when you get it, a whole world opens up. I think that’s a lot of what’s missing now, is it’s just the low-hanging fruit of things that sound like things that sound like things that sound like things that never even really existed in the first place, these templates that were artificial from the very get-go.
Velvet Einstein: Yeah, and I think for myself and obviously for you and a lot of KALX listeners…I hope that the listeners really aren’t caught up in that stream, because I have heard that it’s that notion of the algorithm picking the next song, whereas when you listen to KALX you’ve got the DJ picking the next song, not you, and all you can do is just change the station because the song’s bad. And honestly, sometimes I’ll play a bad song, right? Well, I don’t know if I will.
Ian Brennan: Yeah.
Velvet Einstein: That’s a good question. That brings up the notion of what IS a good song versus a bad song? Can you actually rate something, right? I think at the time that I play the song, the song is great. 10 years later, I may go back and cringe, like that was actually pretty bad. But a song doesn’t exist as a concrete item that can be rated. And it’s more such that it’s something that you have to take into consideration that where you’re at in the environment in which the song exists. Do you agree with that?
Ian Brennan: Yeah, absolutely. And so it’s context. And I think that’s where people that are ahead of their time oftentimes age well. And other people that were maybe successful for whatever reason, maybe it was promotional or image or some other factors, just luck, a lot of times there’s not that same connection. But I’ve always believed in this idea of… In the old days, let’s say you’d have bands that had platinum records, but then they’d come to town and they couldn’t sell tickets because people weren’t really connected to them on an emotional level.
And yet the music that might be underground might only have 50,000 fans, but they are diehard. Like, every person that buys that record is going to go see that band if they can when they come, or that artist when they come to town. And smaller place probably, but, you know, they’re going to sell it out, and maybe their audience is going to grow.
And so this I think is an important part of it as well. But I also think there’s a danger in just valuing obscurity. You know, there’s that whole thing of well this is the artist that got skipped over and people want to go back and create this narrative like they were shorted in some way, like they deserved more attention.
It’s like, no, a lot of times, they were a lesser version of what was more popular. Not that they were bad, but that’s why they didn’t succeed sometimes. And then sometimes there’s something that truly deserved attention, like Nick Drake, that did not, and it becomes timeless. But I think it’s all about the timelessness, and the timelessness is usually something that isn’t chasing an audience, and isn’t chasing a trend, and isn’t chasing a fad.
And it’s hard to not do that. I mean, in the old days, and even now, I think with the big corporations, the people that are signed to these 360-degree deals with the corporations for everything, for merchandising, they push them into acting, they push them into fashion design, they push them into everything. Aside from those people, maybe it doesn’t happen as much as it used to, but it used to be a lot of pressure on artists, like wear the skinny jeans, and let’s put this person in front in the pictures even though they’re the person who’s least involved musically, but they’re the cutest.
They wouldn’t say those words, but that’s what they would do. And so I think there’s maybe less of that, but it’s dangerous how the music, when it’s made not for intrinsically rewarding reasons, it’s almost bound that with time it’s going to fade. And if it doesn’t, it’s almost like a lucky, happy accident, you know?
Because good music can, meaning resonant music that universally moves people, can come from a lot of places, even places that shouldn’t, so to speak. Something like The Monkees, some of the songs stand up much better than artists that were more respected. So it’s complicated, but I think that in general, the people that are really playing music just out of a need to communicate are the ones that stand the test of time because you listen to them and it doesn’t sound like it’s timestamped that it was the psychedelic era. It just sounds like a person who was singing.
Velvet Einstein: Yeah. A great segue to, to bring us back to some of your recent recordings. Let me make sure I get the name right here, the Red Spirit Singers. Can you talk a little bit about coming into contact with them and, and the music they’re making? Because that certainly seems like a very traditional set of music, but also very contemporary.
Ian Brennan: Yeah, the Red Spirit Singers are a multigenerational familial group of the Ute people in northeastern Utah, and they began in the ’80s as a way to try to promote language preservation because there’s only 3,000 speakers left of their language.
So now it’s carried on by… the elders are now the people that were quite young, even children when the group began, and now the next generation is also involved. And so when we recorded, it was 10 drummers who every drummer sings, and then with the addition of three female singers who are not always there, but in this case they were.
So 13 singers and 10 drums, and it was one of the loudest things I’ve ever recorded. I mean, it was just massive sound, and they’re all banging on one big drum for most of the songs that they do. They have some with individual drums, and some with a a metal drum that they all play together. But otherwise, they’re beating on this one big drum.
I think it’s so important because a lot of the Native American music plays into stereotypes, and so there’s a record that just came out this year as well from a group in Southern California, and the first track starts with the sound of birds. And it’s like that doesn’t sound like…that sounds like a producer’s idea. It’s not birds where they were recording outdoors because they weren’t recording outdoors, and it’s got a lot of flutes. Well that sounds like something that exists but isn’t true to every culture.
What the Red Spirit Singers are doing is a very real living tradition, and there’s some truly progressive elements to it as well, bringing in some pop elements in the lyrics and in the melodies, bringing in some nuances that oftentimes are kind of denied with the generic idea that somehow the music all over North America would be the same when there were these diverse people, and still are these diverse people from the different areas.
Velvet Einstein: And as you were recording them, what was the focus in selecting the tracks? Were these all pieces that they had been performing on a regular basis, or did they come up with new material knowing that they were going to be recorded?
Ian Brennan: Most of these are songs they’ve been doing for a while. I mean, what they did in general was most people in the group had a song that would be like, “Oh, I’m gonna do this of my songs.” You know, like the songs that were kind of theirs that either they’d written or they’re the lead singer for, the call singer for that particular song. So they were just kind of taking turns like that. “Okay, you wanna do one? Okay, I’ll do this one. You wanna do one? Okay, I’ll do this one.”
And then there was some stuff that was improvisational as well. I think that mix is important, and the album ends, officially ends… I mean there’s a bonus track that’s quite interesting, but the official end of the album is Joseph, who’s from the younger generation, and he played by himself and it’s very moving.
And in contrast to this massive group sound of 10 singers and 13 singers and 10 drummers. And yet there was some reluctance, like when question came up again, like, “Hey, does anybody wanna do a solo song?” Everybody was like, “Uh,” you know. And some of them it was because they wanted to be done.
But a lot of them it’s because they really didn’t want to play except as a group. But he was the one who was willing to do that. And it’s such a poignant performance really. And it’s quite long. It’s a five-minute performance that he had not planned to do. And there’s just such a longing in his voice and in just the feeling that he evokes.
Velvet Einstein: You’ve been listening to an interview with producer Ian Brennan, talking there about the recent recording, Land of the Sun, Ute Nation, Utah, by the Red Spirit Singers. And we’ll hear the piece he was just talking about in a moment. But I want to let you all know that you’re listening to 90.7 KALX Berkeley, online at kalx.berkeley.edu.
All right, so getting back to the music here. This is the Red Spirit Singers. This is the track Alone, as performed by Joseph, as mentioned by Ian a moment ago.
Musical Interlude
Velvet Einstein: You just heard from the Red Spirit Singers, a song called Alone from the release Land of the Sun, Ute Nation, Utah. That’s produced by Ian Brennan, and we heard an interview with him preceding that. And many thanks to Ian for coming in. And tune in next week at two o’clock, when I’m going to air the second half of that interview with him. I’ve been your host, Velvet Einstein. I am the Thursday twelve-thirty to three PM guy.


